vasus

After delaying the game one day before launch from the 20th to the 27th due to problems with steam not approving their early access build (source), the Bitcraft team has just received approval and decided to take back most of the delay, choosing to launch tomorrow on June 21st, 9 AM EDT (source)

The game had a popular demo in the recent Steam Next Fest and I'm definitively thinking of jumping in tomorrow. What are your thoughts on the title?

I'm gonna be talking about two games, so I want to start with a description of both incase you haven't heard of them:

Brighter Shores is a newly released MMORPG from one of the original creators of RuneScape. This isometric, point-and-click game openly embraces its inspiration from the creator’s previous work. However, aside from this connection, little was known about it prior to launch.

Cube World is an open-world RPG that initially launched with great success in an alpha release back in 2013, only to be abandoned by its developers shortly after. In 2019, the game was released on Steam in an updated beta version, which is the one I'll be mentioning.

When Cube World launched on Steam it came with many changes, but perhaps the biggest one was the newly implemented Region system. No longer could you freely explore the world however you wanted and slowly progress your character with vertical power boosts. Instead, both your combat equipment and traveling tools were location bound to the zone where you first found them, with the only permanent progression being insignificant out-of-combat perks.

This design led to a repetitive gameplay loop: enter a zone, gradually grind for better gear, unlock travel tools like gliders, defeat the boss, earn a small permanent boost (such as a +2.1% swimming speed increase), and then move to the next zone to repeat the process.

This was AWFUL.

Not only is the whiplash of suddenly going from hero to zero for no good reason going to instantly get the majority of your players quitting the game then and there, what exactly does a mechanic like this even solve? Instead of trying to find a way to improve on the flaws of the existing system - which made progression feel pointless at times due to enemies scaling to your level, or gave you no reason to return to low level zones - you are now forced to essentially play a new character in every region. Ok? How is this any better?

Anyway, finally onto Brighter shores. Uniquely, this game is split into distinct pieces called Episodes, where each offers its own area, story and skills. With the game's launch yesterday, players quickly found out that your combat skills and gear both do not carry over between these episodes. Worse still, even your non-combat skills like Cooking or Foraging either have a very limited interaction with other episode content, or are straight up only useable within this one space.

Why? Not only is it clear that a majority of players are put off by a system like this (as seen in the Steam reviews), but for a game that proudly embraces its RuneScape heritage to impose strict limits on how skills interact—and which ones you can use—feels contradictory. Make it make sense.

As a sidenote - some people have dug up the developer's previous comments on progression, and are now speculating that these early episodes serve as a kind of tutorial, after which you will reach zones where the limits on skills are more relaxed. This to me does not make sense, specifically because of the zone combat skills. They are basically copies of one another with a different name, as they use the same exact gear and have no gameplay differences. Surely, if they were supposed to be made available simultaneously later on, they would have some strengths and weaknesses comparatively?

Anyway, finally getting to the core of this post, on why I am mentioning these two games together. When Cube World launched on Steam, there was a ton of negativity and criticism early on. Seemingly everyone hated it, and you could barely find one positive thing about it. But only 24 hours later and there was a complete 180. If you were active in the game's communities on Steam, Youtube, Reddit, Discord etc, you were suddenly swamped with people finding reasons why the Region system is actually great, how it has huge potential, how you cannot criticize the game because it's in Early access (???).

In reality, the people who professed love to this awful Region system were just doing it for... i don't know. Love of the developer? Trying to combat toxicity on the internet? Who knows. What I can say for certain is that it was all just lip service as they didn't like the system either, given that the game essentially lost all of it's playerbase a month or so post launch.

Now in that game's case, it was all ultimately a pointless discussion because the devs took the money and ran for the second time. So no matter the public opinion, nothing would have ever changed. But it seems the same cycle is happening to Brighter Shores. I really hope that in this case, players could learn from history of games like Cube World, like Helldivers 2, like Space marine 2 etc and understand that, even if you personally think a system is OK or even fun, you should consider the opinions of the majority and admit to issues, rather than trying to constantly blow smoke up Andrew Gower's ass while stonewalling all concerns.

You can find a game fun and you can want the developer to suceed all while allowing people to share criticism and ask for improvements. The game's purportedly in Early access, and if that word means what you think it means then now's the last time for big changes to be made - like rethinking this awful episode system that will kill the game.

Thanks for reading, let me know your thoughts. I had to put this stuff to paper, infuriating to see history repeat again.

Steam Next Fest, which is a regular event for showcasing upcoming games, is happening now on steam and will continue until February 12 at 10:00 AM PST (UTC-8).

With hundreds of demos available, even if you're only interested in a fraction of the games it's going to be difficult to try everything before the event ends. With that in mind, I'm hoping people can use this thread to share their thoughts on the titles they've played.

Which games did you enjoy, and which do you think suck? Please share your thoughts!

Genfanad, short for Generic Fantasy Adventure, used to be a browser-based parody/clone of OldSchool runescape with a very sarcastic and self aware sense of humor. If you're a fan of Josh Strife Hayes, you've probably seen his video on it a year back. I've never really played it myself, but I randomly checked the website today and found that the game transformed into some sort of MMO card battler hybrid?

Not going to lie that combination sounds super interesting to me but I'm very confused on why such a huge shift happened in the game's development direction. I had to check the date to make sure it's not April 1st.

Are there any fans of the game here that know why this happened, or want to share their feelings on the change/the state of the game? I've found very few people talking about it online

It's been a while since the open beta started, I haven't tried the game myself but if you did, do you recommend it? I would love to hear your thoughts about it in general, I'm interested in the game but haven't seen many reviews yet

I don't think the announcement is up on their website, but you can see it here on their Discord.

If you're never heard of it, it's an indie MMO that's going for an oldschool feel with the unique feature of dungeon masters interacting with the players live. You can see that it's super janky, but it has some charming features like the classes and the setting. It was previously set to release Q3 2023.

Alongside the name change, they've also announced a rework of the combat system and removed the release date estimate.

I barely follow the game's development so maybe this delay was something that could be seen from miles away but I personally thought the game would be a fun way to pass a few weeks, especially given that there's not much else in the MMO space that's coming out soon besides Palia. In my opinion, I think this game is destined to have a niche following before petering out some months after release, and a combat rework by itself won't change that, it's just wasting time and money.

Were you aware that the game existed at all? And how do you feel about the changes?

With the curent Steam summer sale going on, most MMORPGs on there are going to be on sale. Which titles do you think are worth picking up? If you bought anything new, how do you feel about it?