this post was submitted on 26 May 2025
340 points (94.5% liked)
Communism
2218 readers
33 users here now
Welcome to the communist Lemmy community! This is a community for all Marxist.
founded 5 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
I know it's a meme, but if it doesn't work because of the USA, then that is one of the reasons it doesn't work.
Edit: and you being angry at me just shows your inability to imagine a way forward. "If the USA hadn't stopped us then it would have worked!" Is as smart as saying pigs could fly only if they had wings.
Edit2: I can't imagine why people would think communists are hateful beings.
The USA had better fossil fuels and by better fossil fuels I mean more coal.
The Soviet Union fell because it mostly had to rely on oil and had no solution against the US petrodollar scheme.. China is already doing better with just half as much coal.
Even cultist theocracies could win against communism with enough energy/electricity sources packed in a small area that can't be easily transported.
This coal advantage is quickly disappearing as solar power and to a lesser extend, wind power, is making inroads. By 2030, coal will be a curse like oil as it's easier to transport than solar and wind, which aren't transportable at all.
You say it like the fall of the USSR regime was a bad thing.
it was a good thing - what came after it was a bad thing.
ultimately what happened is that, confronted with either advancing the revolution or burocratizing the party cadres, the ussr chose the last one. the result could be no other than the restoration of capitalism. so far just cuba seems to be resisting this trend, but for how long?
"Advancing the revolution" of course being a shorthand for "spending all resources on exporting it like Trotsky wanted, only to end up failing externally and internally" rather than building up production so that it could actually afford to support revolution around the world, which it did in cases like Cuba, Palestine, Algeria, and more.
The dissolution of the Soviet Union was a complicated factor, but it was by no means because they chose to develop, rather than get themselves wiped out immediately like Trotsky wanted. There are many Socialist nations today, the PRC is by far the biggest and most relevant example on the global stage, it isn't just Cuba.
True.
Cuba is a real dictatorship though, not really the country of the people IMO.
Instead of repeating western progaganda, you could use your time to inform yourself about Cuban democracy and how that democracy is superior to western liberal democracies.
"Cuban democracy" aren't they the epitome of communism??
Are you under the impression that Socialist economies and democracy are at odds with each other? Socialism is more comprehensively democratic for a much larger portion of the population than western-style liberal democracies, as Socialist democracy is run by and for the working class, while liberal democracy is run by and for the Capitalist class.
you got it wrong.
Oh aah, that clear things up so well, thank you for the thorough explanation!
You made the original claim, back yourself up.