This is an automated archive made by the Lemmit Bot.
The original was posted on /r/eu4 by /u/Alfred_Leonhart on 2025-06-18 12:18:48+00:00.
Scene: A sunlit garden in Athens. Socrates sits on a stone bench, stroking his beard, while Plato arrives carrying a scroll titled Europa Universalis IV: Military Mechanics.
⸻
Socrates:
Tell me, Plato, what is it that you clutch so eagerly in your hands?
Plato:
A most curious treatise, Socrates. It concerns the art of war in a realm of simulation, where kingdoms rise and fall not by sword but by calculation. In it, two virtues of the army are praised: morale and discipline.
Socrates:
Ah, then let us inquire into their natures. For what is morale, and what is discipline?
Plato:
Morale, my teacher, is the spirit of the soldier—his will to fight, to endure, to stand firm in the line. Without it, even the most splendid army flees like frightened children.
Socrates:
And discipline?
Plato:
Discipline is the order, the formation, the mastery of technique. It is the sharpened edge of the sword, the precision with which one strikes.
Socrates:
So then, let me ask: which of these two makes for the greater army?
Plato:
Discipline, surely. An army that strikes truer and suffers less from each blow shall always triumph, even if their hearts waver. A force of precision breaks the enemy swiftly and decisively. Is that not the very definition of victory?
Socrates:
And yet, Plato, if those disciplined soldiers turn and flee before the battle is done, what becomes of their fine strikes? What use is precision if it is abandoned in the moment of crisis?
Plato:
But discipline contains within it the ordering of the soul. The soldier trained to obey does not flee easily.
Socrates:
Ah, but now you speak of the effects of discipline upon morale. And I wonder—perhaps morale is the foundation, and discipline the adornment. Consider this: when Sparta met Persia at Thermopylae, did they prevail through precision? Or was it the sheer unshakable resolve to hold the line, even unto death?
Plato:
That may be so for the early fight, teacher. But in a long war, it is not the fiery heart that wins—it is the army that delivers death more efficiently. Just as in this simulation you so curiously entertain, morale might hold the line, but only discipline wins the war.
Socrates:
Perhaps we must ask another question, then. Does one endure, or does one prevail? If the aim is to stand longer, morale is king. If the aim is to conquer quickly, discipline rules.
Plato:
And yet, in this realm, a battle lost is a thousand men dead. Speed in war is mercy. Discipline is the path to peace.
Socrates:
A cunning turn of phrase, Plato. You speak like a general now. But I remain a lover of wisdom, and I say: the soldier who fights on after his comrades fall, who holds the line even when outnumbered—that is the soul of the army. And that is morale.
⸻
Narrator:
Thus, they walked on, each convinced in part by the other. For as in philosophy, so in war—both spirit and form are needed, lest the edifice collapse.