this post was submitted on 04 Sep 2023
47 points (100.0% liked)
chapotraphouse
13894 readers
662 users here now
Banned? DM Wmill to appeal.
No anti-nautilism posts. See: Eco-fascism Primer
Slop posts go in c/slop. Don't post low-hanging fruit here.
founded 4 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
maybe it wouldn't be traumatic then, but hivemind status is orthogonal to gender and contingent on the type of hivemind. outside of unimatrix zero, which is arguably not "the borg". and the character of the borg queen who probably doesn't have a human concept of gender, the borg don't seem to have gender at all
That's an exclusionary thing to say with a swarmgender not-person in the room.
fuck off
I'm OP. You fuck off, and maybe make it clear whether you think my gender is valid first.
mammal hiveminds in fiction run the gamut from individuals who are constantly connected telepathically yet retain recognizable individuality to groups where the individual is only a meat robot. the gender identity of the "members" of any given hivemind is different in each depiction, each fictional universe's rules.
you're perfectly welcome to identify with a concept of gender that is impossible to explain to others but you aren't the sole arbiter of what hiveminds are or what writers decide about the genders of members of hiveminds.
and for completeness, multiple personalities in one mind is also not usually what anyone means when we say "hive mind" but even if we do for the sake of avoiding a tangent i don't care about, the gender identities of people in that situation are varied as well.
yeah that's how it goes when terms are poorly defined, concepts are as abstract as possible, and someone makes absurd claims about the interiority of fictional characters created and written by distant third parties.
There is no academic literature, because the culture responsible for producing academic literature ever since the Enlightenment has historically been transphobic, and only took gender dysphoria out of the DSM in 2013. You think there's a book out there explaining every single nonbinary gender identity? No, there are thousands of nonbinary gender identities. What field of academia do you even want to hear from? Biology? We're a gender, not a sex. History? We don't have any, there aren't enough of us. Physics? Math? Not relevant. Anthropology? There aren't any established populations of us because we're born at random at a very low frequency within a transphobic society. Psychiatry? Being swarmgender isn't an illness.
I mean even though society is transphobic it still manages to produce "research" or really just any discussion at all on the subject. I couldn't find a single article or the like. I'm just used to queer identities having some sort of representation in the LGTBQ sphere, rather than just popping up on a website with seemingly no history - like neopronouns didn't just come from out of nowhere.
While you say swarmgender isn't a mental illness, you also admit that the psychiatric field has a history of cataloguing gender identities diverging from the binary. While non-binary isn't a mental illness, it was still studied enough to be in the DSM, so it's existence was known - it was just treated with bigotry.
I don't think of any specific field, but usually there is something, anything really.
Well, I had to figure out my gender all on my own. It took years, after I had already become an expert on queer theory. But here, this might help:
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Identity_fusion
Appreciated 👍